top of page

Decorated Sugar Cookies

All decorated sugar cookies come individually packaged in a heat-sealed cellophane bag with an ingredient label on the backside. Individual gift boxes or bows is an additional charge.

​​

Flavors — signature (vanilla + imitation almond extract) or vanilla only ​

 

​*Custom cookie sets are limited to a maximum of 4 designs per dozen* â€‹â€‹â€‹

Mini Cookies

$30/dozen

  • 2-2.5"

  • 2 dozen minimum

  • Budget-friendly option for large events and kids parties

$33/dozen 

  • natural dyes (plant based)

Printed Cookies

$42/dozen

  • 3-4"

  • 1 dozen minimum

  • Iced plain white & images are printed on

  • No icing details

​

CANNOT be made dye-free

Regular cookies

$54/dozen

  • 3-4"

  • 1 dozen minimum

  • Iced any color, background may be printed for patterns and pictures

  • Icing details

$60/dozen

  • natural dyes (plant based)

Cookie DIY Kits

Individual Kits — 8 naked sugar cookies (4 shapes) , 5 colors of royal icing (1 outline and 4 flood), 1 3D printed cookie scribe & 1 practice sheet. â€‹

​

Bulk Kits — Up to 4 shapes per dozen. Does not include individual icing bags - you will get large bags with icing to share among the group. Designed for larger groups who aren't focused on perfecting their cookies!​

​

All kits can be purchased ahead and frozen to decorate at a later date. All kits will come with instructions for decorating and storage. 

Individual KIT

$30/each kit

Bulk kit

$25/dozen cookies

naked cookies only

$18/dozen cookies

Mini Cookie Bites

Packaged in resealable bags,  1.5" circles or hearts with a dollop of royal icing — perfect for increasing your cookie count, or for a small little treat whenever you need. There are no details!! â€‹

Standard Flavors signature (vanilla + imitation almond extract) or vanilla only

​

Specialty Flavors — blueberry lemon, raspberry lemon, strawberry lemon, snickerdoodle, white chocolate raspberry​​

Standard Flavors

$10/dozen

specialty flavors 

$12/dozen

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes 

8" chocolate chip cookie cake with vanilla buttercream frosting​

8" square

$25 each​

Cakes + Cupcakes

While our specialty is decorated sugar cookies, we are also starting to dabble in simple cupcakes and smash cakes. Our cupcakes are a simple swirl of frosting with one color. Smash cakes and vintage heart cakes may increase in price depending on level of detail requested.

​

Cake Flavors chocolate, lemon, red velvet, strawberry, vanilla, white wedding cake

(1 flavor per dozen for regular size, 1 flavor per 2 dozen for minis)

​

Frosting Optionsvanilla buttercream, whipped frosting​​

smash cakes

$30+

  • 5" round or 6" heart

Mini Cupcakes

$12/dozen

  • ​2 dozen minimum

  • Simple swirl only

Regular Cupcakes

$24/dozen​

  • 1 dozen minimum​

  • Simple swirl

  • Can add simple details

Pull-apart cakes

$50-$100

  • 24-48 reg size cupcakes

  • Numbers, letters, or a shape

  • For double digits or letters 48 cupcakes is suggested

natural dyes

Please note, that with plant-based natural food colorings, icing/frosting colors will not be as vibrant, and may not match your party colors exactly. Plant-based food coloring will only be used for your order upon special request as the default for all orders is artificial food dyes. Pricing varies for cake products depending on size/quantity. Please submit an inquiry for an accurate quote.

Michaela's cookies.png

michaelascookies1@gmail.com

Fishers, IN 46038

(p/u in Greenfield, IN 46140 available)

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

©2021 by Michaela's Cookies. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page